Houston Community College System Underpants Sees Scientist Dismissed Over Test that Trapped Cheating Husband Case Study – Description
Case Information:
CSI: Underpants Sees Scientist Dismissed Over Test that Trapped Cheating Husband
by James Bone, Times Online on August 22, 2007.
Ann Chamberlain ran a DNA test on her husband’s underwear in the crime laboratory where she was employed since 1999, to determine if he was cheating. She then testified to conducting this investigation at the divorce hearing. The DNA test was discovered when her husband’s lawyer sent a letter to her Michigan State Police laboratory questioning the improper DNA testing. Although Ann had won awards for her work and testified in more than 50 cases, she was fired for misusing the crime laboratory.
Chamberlain stated that the tests were conducted outside of work hours with expired chemicals. It was later discovered through court testimony that she had previously conducted a paternity test for one of her husband’s friends and allowed him access to the laboratory while she ran his sample.
So where does everyone stand on the issue? The Michigan State Police suspended her with pay while conducting the investigation. After the investigation was completed, they fired Chamberlain for violating state policy. Her husband’s lawyer feels that she should face criminal charges for stealing from taxpayers. The president of Forensic Science Consultants, where Chamberlain also works, stated that she is an excellent scientist who made an error in judgment caused by stress.
After hearing the different views of the issue, whom do you most agree with? Why?
After hearing the different views of the issue, whom do you most disagree with? Why?
Was there unethical behavior?
Do you feel that the behavior was unethical or a mistake?
What was the unethical behavior that occurred?
How was the unethical behavior rectified?
What circumstances do you feel may have led to these behaviors?
Do you feel that the agency could have prevented the unethical act?
Was it unethical on a personal level?
Do you agree with the outcome?
What steps could have been taken to minimize the outcome/lessen the impact?
What could have / should have been done differently?
The post Houston Community College System Underpants Sees Scientist Dismissed Over Test that Trapped Cheating Husband Case Study first appeared on .
